After crashing out of the CAF Champions League at the hands of Egyptian outfit Pyramids FC, Mamelodi Sundowns’ quest for a second continental title came to a disappointing end — and now, some pundits and fans believe the club’s biggest problem has finally been exposed: they might be “playing too much football.”
The South African champions were widely tipped as favourites to go all the way in this year’s CAF Champions League after a strong run of form both domestically and on the continent. However, their failure to overcome a resilient Pyramids side in the crucial knockout stages has raised questions about their tactical approach and squad management.
One recurring criticism? That Sundowns’ possession-heavy, high-tempo playing style, while attractive and dominant in the DStv Premiership, may be too demanding over the course of a season crammed with domestic, continental, and now international fixtures.
A Style That’s Beautiful… but Risky?
Sundowns have built a reputation for being South Africa’s most stylish and technically gifted team. With their short passing, high pressing, and fluid build-up play, they often control matches from start to finish. But critics argue that this expansive style requires near-perfect execution, mental sharpness, and physical endurance — something hard to maintain over a full season.
“Sometimes it looks like they want to play the perfect game every time,” said one local analyst. “But in the Champions League, especially in the knockout stages, it’s not always about playing pretty football. It’s about getting the job done.”
Burnout and Fixture Congestion
The club’s congested schedule might also be a factor. Between league duties, cup competitions, and continental campaigns, Sundowns’ core players have been stretched thin. The addition of the upcoming FIFA Club World Cup in 2025 only adds to the load, increasing concerns about fatigue and injuries.
Despite having one of the deepest squads in Africa, the technical team may need to rethink their rotation policy and tactical discipline to adapt better to knockout football.
What’s Next?
While disappointment lingers, there’s still hope. The experience gained, especially among younger players, could prove valuable heading into next season. The technical team now faces a critical period of reflection: can they find a balance between their ambitious brand of football and the ruthlessness required to win big titles?
Until then, the phrase “Sundowns play football too much” may linger — not as a compliment, but as a caution.
